Running a Cafe
Share
Why do customers become regulars?
People don’t become regulars because of coffee alone.
They become regulars because they feel seen.
The best cafes create a genuine sense of belonging. Staff remember names, usual orders, and small details from past conversations, making every visit feel familiar and welcoming.
Yes, customers are buying a coffee.
But they’re also buying into your culture, your community, and your identity.
People want to feel like they’re part of something.
The key is consistency. Show up day after day, keep familiar faces behind the bar, and allow your staff to take ownership of their role - not just as baristas, but as part of the business itself.
Your staff are characters, and people love characters. That familiarity builds connection, and that connection builds loyalty - to both your team and your cafe.
Invest in genuine relationships, and your customers will keep coming back long after they’ve forgotten what they ordered the first time.
Is coffee quality enough on its own?
No.
And honestly, sometimes it's not even half the picture.
Great coffee gets people through the door.
Great hospitality brings them back.
We've all visited cafes serving exceptional coffee that feel cold or unwelcoming. We've also all been to cafes where the coffee wasn't world-class, yet the place was packed because people loved the atmosphere.
The best cafes combine both.
Never choose between coffee quality and customer service.
Aim to master both.
How often should cafes adjust pricing?
This is a funny question because before 2020, many cafes barely changed their prices for years.
Then the world changed.
Coffee prices, wages, milk, rent, electricity, insurance and freight all increased dramatically.
Today, we'd recommend reviewing your pricing at least seasonally and paying particular attention to coffee prices every year.
That doesn't mean you need to increase your prices every year.
It simply means you need to know your numbers.
The economy is constantly changing whether we like it or not. Your pricing should evolve with it.
How do I train staff for consistency?
First, become consistent yourself.
Excuse the pun, but you need to be dialled in.
As the owner, you need to understand coffee. This isn't optional.
You don't have to be Australia's best barista, but you should know enough to train your staff, recognise problems and understand what great coffee looks like.
If you don't care about coffee, why should your staff?
Lead from the front and build clear recipes, create systems and train everyone the same way. Consistency starts with leadership.
How do I reduce waste?
Most waste comes from poor systems rather than bad staff. So simple systems make a huge difference.
Use scales to weigh coffee.
Mark milk jugs with fill lines.
Create written recipes.
Have staff read orders back to customers before making them.
Label storage clearly.
None of these ideas are revolutionary, but together they reduce mistakes, save money and make your team more consistent without them even realising it.
How important is customer service?
It's everything.
If we had to choose between average coffee and exceptional customer service or incredible coffee with terrible service, we'd choose the first option every time.
People remember how you made them feel, whether you smiled or greeted them. Whether you thanked them or if you genuinely cared they were there.
Most customers won't remember exactly how their eggs were cooked six months ago but they'll absolutely remember whether they felt welcome.
How do I create a great cafe culture?
Be the culture, it is really that simple.
Culture isn't something you write on a wall it's what your team experiences every day and if you're negative, impatient or difficult to work with, that becomes your culture.
If you're encouraging, hardworking and respectful, that becomes your culture too. People follow behaviour far more than they follow policies.
If you want a positive team, become the kind of leader people genuinely enjoy working with.
How do I avoid burnout as a cafe owner?
Burnout doesn't happen overnight.
It usually happens because owners try to carry everything themselves for too long.
Start by building a business that looks after both you and your team.
Give people proper days off, allow sick leave without making people feel guilty, pay people fairly and celebrate good work.
Sometimes send people home early if the day allows it - and still pay them.
Set high expectations, absolutely. But never forget your staff are people before they're employees.
Healthy businesses are built by healthy teams.
What income streams should cafes consider?
Selling coffee across the counter shouldn't be your only source of income.
At Moon Boy, we have multiple revenue streams through our cafe, online bean sales and wholesale coffee.
For cafes, there are plenty of opportunities to diversify.
Offer online ordering through platforms like Bopple.
Use Uber Eats or other delivery services - but make sure you increase your prices to cover the commission. Convenience has value, and customers expect to pay for it.
Sell retail coffee beans.
Offer brewing equipment.
Run events.
Build a strong social media presence.
Even branded merchandise can work if your community genuinely loves your business.
The goal is to avoid relying on one income stream alone.
What mistakes do new cafe owners make?
Trying to own a cafe without actually being involved.
Hospitality isn't the type of business you can simply open and expect someone else to run successfully from day one.
At least in the beginning, you need to be there. To support your staff, build systems, solve problems, learn your customers and most importantly understand your numbers.
Hospitality is one of the most competitive industries there is.
If you want your business to succeed, you need your finger on the pulse.
What's one piece of advice you'd give every cafe owner?
Never stop improving yourself.
Educate yourself in coffee, customer service become a conversationalist by deepening you gift of the gab.
To do this and become more confident talking to people, practice. Talk to your customers, talk about yourself and your life - and ask about theirs. Overtime these conversations because so natural you won't recognise yourself.
Learn basic maintenance. Fridges, coffee machines, grinders, aircon, dishwasher. You will need to know how these items work in order to understand how to fix and maintain them.
Understand your numbers. Enough said.
Become the person your business needs you to be. You'll wear almost every hat at some point. Then, once you understand each role, learn how to delegate it to someone who can eventually do it even better than you.
Ask the Roaster
Is expensive coffee really better?
Sometimes.
It depends what you're trying to achieve.
If you're brewing filter coffee and want to experience all the unique flavours a coffee has to offer, spending a little more on a high-quality single origin can absolutely be worth it.
But if you're creating an everyday espresso blend, spending 30% more on green coffee doesn't necessarily mean your customers will enjoy it 30% more.
The goal isn't to buy the most expensive coffee.
The goal is to buy the right coffee.
Are tasting notes mostly marketing?
Sometimes... yes.
Usually not intentionally.
Tasting notes are simply people's attempts to describe incredibly complex flavours.
Coffee doesn't literally taste like blueberries or caramel.
Those notes are references to flavours our brains recognise from other foods.
Some tasting notes are incredibly accurate.
Others can be a little... optimistic.
Treat them as a guide rather than a guarantee.
Why do some specialty cafes intimidate people?
Because they sometimes forget not everyone knows what they know.
Most customers have never heard of Geisha varieties, washed processing or anaerobic fermentation.
So when a barista asks whether you'd like the natural Colombian batch brew and you reply, "Yes, on full cream," then gets frustrated, that's an intimidating experience.
Our job isn't to make customers feel silly.
It's to make coffee approachable.
The best cafes educate without making people feel excluded.
Has specialty coffee become too complicated?
In some ways, yes.
Coffee is complicated.
There are countless varieties, processing methods, roasting techniques and brewing variables.
But that doesn't mean drinking coffee needs to be complicated.
One of Moon Boy's core beliefs is that we should do the complicated work behind the scenes so our customers don't have to.
That's what "Uncompromised Standards. Uncomplicated Coffee." means to us.
Are coffee competitions relevant to everyday cafes?
Not really.
Competitions push the industry forward and showcase incredible talent, but running a successful neighbourhood cafe requires a completely different skill set.
Your customers care far more about consistency, hospitality and feeling welcome than whether you've won a trophy.
Is light roast overrated?
No.
Like every roast style, it has its place.
Some of our customers love light roasts.
Others only want medium or darker coffees.
None of those preferences are wrong.
Coffee isn't about following trends.
It's about drinking what you enjoy.
Why do some cafes serve great coffee but still fail?
Usually one of two reasons.
Either the business fundamentals aren't there - they don't know their numbers, they aren't charging correctly or they're poorly managed.
Or the market has simply become more competitive.
Great coffee alone doesn't guarantee a successful business.
You still need great leadership, hospitality, marketing and financial management.
Should cafes roast their own coffee?
Not unless they genuinely want to become a coffee roaster as well.
Roasting is a completely different business with its own equipment, skills, risks and costs.
For most cafes, partnering with a great roaster allows them to focus on what they do best; looking after customers.
Is customer service now more important than coffee quality?
We don't think one is more important than the other.
They're equally important.
Great coffee without hospitality rarely creates loyal customers.
Great hospitality with poor coffee eventually disappoints people too.
The magic happens when both are exceptional.
Are expensive espresso machines worth it?
Yes - but expensive is relative.
Do you need a $39,000 machine?
Probably not.
Will a better machine make life easier, produce more consistent coffee and create a better workflow?
Absolutely.
Like most equipment, there are diminishing returns.
Buy the best machine that makes sense for your business.
Is there really a "best" coffee?
No.
There's only the best coffee for you.
Coffee is incredibly personal.
Some people love bright, fruity Ethiopian coffees.
Others want rich, chocolatey espresso every morning.
Neither person is wrong.
The best coffee is the one you genuinely enjoy drinking.